A Family Tradition In
Put-in-Bay Since 1949
A Family Tradition In Put-in-Bay Since 1949
Tasty pizza baked fresh to order, peanut shells crunching underfoot, Cold beer served in the signature Frosty beer mug, and live music entertainment are all part of what makes Frosty Bar, The Backyard, and Big Man’s Burrito Stand a favorite spot in Put-in-Bay for generations.
We welcome all service animals both inside and outside on the patio!
Frosty's Hours
Breakfast
7AM-11AM
Pizza & Cold Beer
Sun-Thurs: 11AM-8PM
Fri-Sat 11AM-10PM
Big Man’s Burrito Stand
Big Man’s Burrito Stand will return in 2027!
Breakfast
Pizza & Cold Beer
Big Man’s Burrito Stand
Check Out Our Menus
Breakfast, lunch, dinner and drinks. We’ve got it all at Frosty’s. Check out our amazing burritos, pizzas, cocktails and so much more.
Check Out Our Menus
Breakfast, lunch, dinner and drinks. We’ve got it all at Frosty’s. Check out our amazing burritos, pizzas, cocktails and so much more.
Order Online
Get Frosty’s amazing tacos, pizzas and amazing specialty sandwiches on the go!
Visit our online ordering system to beat the rush and get our amazing food to go!
Visit The Backyard
The Backyard at Frosty’s Bar is fun outdoor venue which serves fresh fruit margaritas, specialty cocktails and offers entertainment under the stars.
Get Your Frosty's On
From gift certificate and souvenirs to shirts and hats, Frosty’s has something for everyone.